Skip to content
  • ABOUT
    • CONTACT
    • POLICY
    • Homepage
  • BLOG
    • GEAR
      • BOOKS
      • ACCESSORIES
      • HELMETS
      • KIT
      • BLOG SHOP
    • LIFESTYLE
      • BEAUTY
      • NUTRITION
      • TRAVEL
    • COMMUTE
      • BIKE STYLE
      • COMMUTER TIPS
    • Aventures
    • ROAD
      • ROAD TIPS
      • TIPS
  • Zines
  • BIKE TALK
  • ABOUT
    • CONTACT
    • POLICY
    • Homepage
  • BLOG
    • GEAR
      • BOOKS
      • ACCESSORIES
      • HELMETS
      • KIT
      • BLOG SHOP
    • LIFESTYLE
      • BEAUTY
      • NUTRITION
      • TRAVEL
    • COMMUTE
      • BIKE STYLE
      • COMMUTER TIPS
    • Aventures
    • ROAD
      • ROAD TIPS
      • TIPS
  • CITYGIRLRIDES

  • Zines
  • BIKE TALK

Bike Talk: A Commentary On The Helmet Debate.

May 25, 2011 CGR 7 comments
Before I start this commentary on the massive debate on helmets, I just want to say that I find it difficult to see how the cycling internet community will misread and tear each other to pieces over this subject. Some of the most exciting people that I had mad love for made we weep with disappointment because of the way they have handled the topic. I know the internet is a public place for people to share information but I personally don’t find it a place to hold a debate of any type. There needs to be a sense of internet etiquette when handling topics as such and well… etiquette isn’t what I see being handed on tabloids, forums, blogs, and twitter. I understand people have their personal stories and data to share on the subject but I think the debate of the bicycle helmet is bigger than we think it is.

I found some interesting articles on the helmet debate after I wrote the last post, I won’t list any to protect them. Although, I did see unnecessary bashing and name calling, I believe “helmet haters” was a title? There was one that said “wearing a helmet is the responsible adult thing to do, shmh!” I even saw some debates being held on twitter, crazy. I wont mention any names but I wish we all could just sit down in the park, throw back some beers and talk about our problems with the helmet debate and hug-it-out.

For many of us who choose not to wear helmets, we accept that people aren’t going to like us, will misunderstand us, and calls us all sorts of names like “HELMET HATERZ!” I accept that but from what I read based on these responses, I find that the concept of not wearing a helmet is too big and hard for people to understand. I know I don’t live in a country were bicycle friendliness is a top priority in our planning policies but perhaps not wearing a helmet for one’s own sense of comfort is a progressive way of thinking that doesn’t measure up when it comes to safety. Yes, it’s about your freedom to choose but we just don’t live in the same countries or have the same policies to protect cyclists.
I don’t think that this debate will end until people start to realize that the energy we spend on worrying about our safety on the road needs to be taken away from the helmet debate and geared towards organizing, writing letters to our city and state demanding laws that protect cyclists on the road, helmet wearing or not. Continuing the debate is like adding more fuel to a fire when it’s done online. It does nothing positive for the cycling community. I’m just one of those lucky people to happen live in a city that takes its cycling community very serious when it comes to urban planning and bicycle infrastructure. Going to a meeting every now and then puts things into perspective for me when dealing with so many issues of community and road safety as there is a lot more involved than just wearing a helmet.

I consider myself to be aware of these experiences and I encourage you to inform yourself of your rights as a cyclist and get involved with your community or bike coalition. Many countries have a long way to go towards bike friendliness and it doesn’t start at a helmet.

Related Posts

Nuance in the “All Bodies on Bikes” Conversation
Nuance in the “All Bodies on Bikes” Conversation
Why For Us, By Us Stories Matter
Why For Us, By Us Stories Matter
TGL Podcast Interview
TGL Podcast Interview
Frontier Narratives and Why We Must Rewrite The Outdoors
Frontier Narratives and Why We Must Rewrite The Outdoors

Post navigation

Bike Talk: Street Harassment
Bike Talk: The Skirt revolution
7 Comments
Newest
Oldest Most Voted
Mike Gordon
Mike Gordon
August 25, 2011 4:16 pm

Wow. Some intense emoting there. Thanks for posting this. That doesn't mean I endorse everything citygirlrides wrote. But I know what she's trying to say, and I concur. So yes, while it is tempting and even a bit addictive, arguing about helmet attitudes probably does those of us interested in making cycling the core of an alternative transportation and city planning concept should probably resist, and let the slings and arrows of those who haven't got that memo pass us by.

0
'Xander Labayen
'Xander Labayen
August 25, 2011 6:26 pm

I totally understand whats going on, and the problem with the helmet debate over social media is that it lacks the physicality of having a table, chair and coffee or beer in front of a real face while having a discussion.

context gets all messed up in virtual land, and assumptions are easily made via email and 140 characters.

if we all had the chance to sit down over coffee and discuss helmets we'd realize that regardless of what side of the debate you ride on that we all have good intentions towards each other.

I appreciate your post!

Cheers..

0
Anonymous
Anonymous
August 25, 2011 8:29 pm

until the law in australia made it compulsory for bike riding people to wear a helmet, i never really heard much on the topic. but now that we are made to wear a helmet, there is endless talk about having our right to choose taken away. put simply these days, whether you like it or not here, caught without a helmet you are fined. it happened to me. in fact the police woman chased me down. she left her random breath testing duties and wrote out that fine with sheer delight. i enjoyed your post. is it not compulsory to… Read more »

0
karmapics
karmapics
August 26, 2011 3:22 am

There are several points on this debate. First off I have no problem with people who choose not to wear helmets. I'm not going to judge those who don't either. I didn't start wearing a helmet until a few yrs ago anyway. Being that Mikael/Copenhagenize is the unofficial 'face' of the anti-helmet campaign according to another blog, he makes convincing arguments against the compulsory-helmet LAWS.And that is where I totally agree. No one should be forced to wear helmets, or anything else for that matter, by cash-strapped governments for the sake of revenue disguised as 'caring.' It's not only a… Read more »

0
citygirlrides
citygirlrides
August 26, 2011 3:34 am

@veronica, in california we are not required by law to wear one but if a cyclist is hit and killed they get blamed for not wearing a helmet. it's completely ridiculous.

@karmapic, i agree with you on how america needs a good lesson. in your last sentence on peds and bicyclist having the right of way, i had an experience watching a sea of parisians walk into red lights and cars stopping for them all to pass through, it was a shocking sight but i fell in love with it.

0
Dave Feucht
Dave Feucht
August 26, 2011 7:34 pm

In Amsterdam, there are basically no stop signs, and quite few traffic signals in general. They will have just a zebra crosswalk painted across a 4 lane road with a tram going down the middle (so a quite large road), and cyclists riding in the cycle path at the right of the road or pedestrians walking on the sidewalk will just cut left across the crosswalk, and everyone stops for them like they were expecting it (because they were). Here, it's like any time someone not in a car is in the street, it's a shock – OMG, there's a… Read more »

0
SOURCE INTERNATIONAL SYSTEMS
SOURCE INTERNATIONAL SYSTEMS
June 16, 2017 9:33 pm

This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

0
WELCOME!

WELCOME!

Christina Torres, Blogger and Zinester


Welcome to my blog, City Girl Rides! Here you'll find musings about my adventures on bike, critiques on cycling culture and advocacy, and tips for a bikey life.

I also make zines at Cyclista Zine.

search…

Bike Talk Zine

Shop!
Bike Talk Zine

Bikey Book Club

Categories

  • ACCESSORIES
  • BEAUTY
  • BIKE STYLE
  • BIKE TALK
  • BOOKS
  • COMMUTE
  • COMMUTER TIPS
  • EVENTS
  • GEAR
  • HELMETS
  • KIT
  • LIFESTYLE
  • MAINTENANCE
  • Musings
  • NUTRITION
  • RIDE JOURNAL
  • ROAD
  • ROAD TIPS
  • SAFETY
  • TIPS
  • TRAVEL
  • Uncategorized
  • WELLNESS
  • Women Lead
  • Zines
  • CONTACT
  • POLICY
© 2026 | © CITY GIRL RIDES by CHRISTINA TORRES.
wpDiscuz